The quick answer is yes. Many skeptics need the long answer. Skeptics were burnt by early braces that did not work. This left them with a bad taste in their mouth. Find out what changed...
Today, braces are made from actual orthotists (people trained in brace making) that have researched mechanics and materials that work for dogs.
To better answer the question for the skeptics, let's look at dog knee braces from 3 different perspectives.
1- Fabric Vs. Plastic Braces
To better answer the question, you need to have a simple understanding of what "bad motion" we are trying to limit with a brace. In dogs, an ACL tear allows a bad motion called a cranial drawer. This motion is the tibia slipping forward under the femur.
This slipping startles your dog because their leg feels unstable. The slipping can be painful too. Over time the slipping causes inflammation that results in arthritis in the joint.
If dogs want to play... they won't really put weight on their foot unless their knee feels stable. And this is likely why they tear the other ACL too.
Fabric braces were the first braces used to address this problem. The big problem is that fabric stretches. Because of this stretching, it is physically impossible to stop the slipping. Thus they didn't work.
Also, fabric braces need some sort of harness to hold them on the leg. The harness made it very complicated to put on. It also limited the motion in the hip joints so your dog could not move very easily.
Today we use plastic that is more durable and can actually limit the bad motion.
Some worry about the comfort of plastic, but I can vouch as an amputee, wearing a stable plastic device is sooo much more comfortable than a fabric piece that rubs back and forth. The fabric feels like a rope burn.
To replace the harness, plastic braces actually form fit around bones so they can stay on the leg. This allows the dog to move more fluidly.
Some are tempted to start with a fabric brace until they can afford a plastic brace. Knowing how well a fabric brace works, you really are better off saving your money until you can afford the support you need.
2- Surgery Vs. Surgery Not Possible
Many people cannot have surgery. Which has lead people to look for other options to help their dogs. Surgeons know surgery works, so it can be hard to look at other options like bracing. In the end we want to help all the dogs.
Surgeries like TPLO or TTA change the geometry of the bones and do not need added support of a brace. Surgeries like lateral suture or extra capsular work better with bracing. Heavier dogs can break the suture in these surgeries. Added support of a brace is beneficial to help prevent too much pressure on the suture to keep it from failing.
Dogs that cannot have surgery need some extra help until their body forms a medial buttress. (The medial buttress is the scar tissue that stabilizes the knee.)
Veterinarians always like to see proof. There have been a studies done by veterinarian colleges to help us know that braces do work. If you are a big researcher you can access those here.
If Not, Here's A quick synopsis.
A study done at Colorado State Veterinary School showed surgery wins out over bracing 98% to 85% for owner satisfaction. So though not perfect, there is merit for bracing dogs that CANNOT have surgery.
University of Georgia Veterinary school did a study in a gait lab (complex measuring camera model.) It showed the braces cause a shift in the knee motion when a dog puts its weight on the leg (when the bad motion happens). Though it is not clear if this means that the brace stops the bad motion.
University of Louisville did a study simulating a dog's leg and a torn ACL, showed the brace did as well as any surgery limiting the bad motion. And that the more rigid the joints, meant the brace did a better job limiting the bad motion.
Most credible companies are supporting more research to validate what they have seen with thousands of successful patients. In the end, there will always be skeptics.
Surgery is best AND if you cannot have surgery for whatever reason, you have to figure out how you can best help your dog.
In human medicine, we do surgery AND a brace because insurance pays for both, In veterinary medicine, generally we choose surgery OR brace.
Ultimately, how you help your dog is your choice.
3- Custom Made Braces Vs. Small, Medium, Large Fits All
People who think brace don't work, likely don't understand this difference. So, let me try to simplify it....
If you were to tear your ACL, you would have 14 different sizes to fit to your leg.
Do you know how many breeds of dogs there are?
The World Canine Organization recognizes 364 different breeds with a wide variety of shapes and sizes.
So, how many different sizes of knee braces for dogs would you need?
14 x 364 = 5096
Okay, this is a large overstatement, but you get the picture. Fitting dogs can be really tough with a few sizes.
It is important to keep in mind the bad motion we are trying to correct. The movement is so small we really need to have a good fitting brace to limit that cranial drawer motion.
Simply put, for dog knees, one size fits all is really one size fits NONE. Ready to fit knee braces do not work. Custom is key to playing again!
Custom just means you have to do a little bit more work up front for the best chance for success. The casting process is pretty simple. Check out our casting tips to help.
Ultimately if you are here, you are trying to help your dog. We want to help you help your dog too!